The Best Valentine Sugar Cookies

Get the recipe for the The Best Valentine Sugar Cookies ever! 

The best valentine sugar cookie recipe on aliceandlois.comIt’s a tradition in my house to make heart shaped cut out sugar cookies for Valentine’s Day, and these Valentine sugar cookies are simply the best. 

We get our love for sugar cookies from our mom. Who in turn got it from her mother. So the tradition of making sugar cookies for the holidays (Valentine’s Day included) runs deep! 

Our mom has even gifted each of her grandchildren this darling children’s book about love and sugar cookies! 

We shared this recipe with you for Christmas, and honestly, it’s too good to not share again! This year, I made five different shades of pink to frost my cookies with. These ombre cuties are gorgeous on a platter and even cuter in a Ball jar to give away as a gift.

You can download the “How Sweet It Is” label here. Read more to see the recipe for the best Valentine sugar cookies and the tempting photos 🙂 I’ve already eaten almost all the cookies…

We also have made mini colorful versions of these cookies as well as a modern color block look!

Read more for The Best Valentine Sugar Cookies recipe.

The Best Valentine Sugar Cookies Recipe

(We love this heart shaped cookie cutter)

Ingredients

1 cup butter, room temperature

1 cup sugar

1 ½ teaspoons vanilla

1 egg

1 teaspoon water (a bit more if needed)

3 cups flour

1 ½ teaspoons baking powder

¼ t salt

heart shaped Valentine sugar cookies

Cream butter, sugar and vanilla.

Add egg and water. Beat until light and fluffy.

In a new bowl, combine flour, baking powder and salt. Sift together.

Blend dry mixture into creamed mixture, divide dough in half. Wrap each half in waxed paper or plastic wrap and chill for one hour.

When you are ready to roll your dough, make sure and flour your working surface. If your dough feels too sticky, add a little bit of flour. If your dough seems to dry, add a tiny bit of water and kneed.

Roll your dough on the floured surface with a rolling pin. We like to roll our about a quarter inch thick.

Bake at 375 degrees for 6-8 minutes. Watch them carefully. Take out of oven before edges turn brown.

Homemade Icing:

Start with 2 cups of powdered sugar. Add 1 teaspoon vanilla and 1 tablespoon melted butter. Stir in teaspoons of milk one at a time until you reach desired consistency.

The best Valentine sugar cookie recipe on aliceandlois.com

The best Valentine sugar cookie recipe on aliceandlois.comTo get the ombre frosting effect for these cookies, all you have to do is make five different shades of pink frosting. I just portion out five bowls of icing, then add some pink food coloring bit by bit to each bowl until I achieve the colors I’m looking for.

Then frost those sweet Valentine sugar cookies up! We love using the gel food coloring to get the rich and bright colors.

We hope The Best Valentine Sugar Cookies will become a Valentine’s tradition for your family! 

heart shaped valentine sugar cookies

We would love to see your cookies! Tag us on instagram @aliceandlois

heart shaped sugar cookies Valentine 

The best Valentine sugar cookie recipe on aliceandlois.com

all photos by Melissa for alice & lois design studios, all rights reserved.

facebook // instagram // pinterest

Similar Posts

119 Comments

  1. So cute! I love that you guys have a valentines day tradition.

  2. These are absolutely beautiful! You have gotten me so inspired!!

  3. Just a question before I try these cookies out…the “t” in the recipe (ex. 1 1/2 t vanilla, 1 t water) stands for Teaspoon not Tablespoon right? Just want to make sure I have the right measurement!!

  4. Hey i was just wondering if it was tablespoon or teaspoon?

  5. Chesney Abel says:

    I was wondering about how many this makes?

    1. You can count on four dozen. I like to roll mine out thick, but you can roll them out to your desired thickness.

        1. I’m sorry to hear this. You can always add a bit more water to get the consistency right.

  6. Lauren Good says:

    So cute! Do you have a print out for your mason jar tags!?

  7. Just tried to make these tonight. Not sure what went wrong but the dough would not roll out, just kept crumbling. 🙁

    1. It sounds like the fat (butter) wasn’t distributed throughout the dough. Also, this could happen if the dough is still too cold. Good luck!

  8. Hiya, I was just windering if the oven temperature is in celcius? Or is it farenheit?

  9. I think it needs another egg:). BTW I’m from CO! I love Crested Butte!!

    1. I use extra large eggs with this recipe, I think that helps. You could try that, or adding another egg. Let me know how that works 🙂
      And fun to hear you live in CO. We just got hammered with snow… it’s been beautiful!
      –Melissa

  10. Does it matter whether the butter is salted or unsalted?

    1. No, my mom swears by salted butter, but I use unsalted in mine, and I think they are still divine!

  11. Katie May says:

    These were truly THE BEST! These are super easy to make, they taste delicious and look like you visited the bakery! PERFECT! Thanks ladies.

  12. I baked these without the icing for valentines day and they were a big hit with my coworkers! I’m going to bake them again for st. Pattys but cut them in shamrock shapes. I would like to make them green. Would adding food coloring have any negative effect on the dough?

  13. I made these yesterday and they turned out perfect! The edges were the perfect crispness and the middle was nice and soft! Everyone loved ’em- Thanks!

  14. Just so you know, I used this recipe for valentines hearts and I’m using it today for halloween ghosts and it’s still delicious! I’m a pretty terrible chef but these are so simple, thanks for sharing.

    1. Thanks for letting us know Sarah! Enjoy.
      Happy Halloween!
      Sara & Melissa

  15. I love these. Would you please tell me how thick you roll yours out? You say thick, but how thick? 1/4″?

    1. Hi Brenda,
      We roll ours out to 1/4 inch. Happy Valentine’s… and enjoy the cookies!
      –Melissa

  16. Wonderful recipe! Great dough to work with….perfect for cookie cutters. I over made dough (not knowing how many cookies I wanted to make). How long to you think they’ll stay fresh in the freezer?

  17. i’VE made these cookies a dozen times -always turn out perfect. thank you for the recipe!

  18. Hey! So far the cookies and icing are amaaaazing! For some reason my icing is not hardening on the cookies and remaining “liquidy”. Any suggestions on how to fix this? I tried refrigerating to see if the icing would harden and now the cookies are cold 🙁 HELP!!!

    1. I would recommend adding more powered sugar to the icing. And you want to ice the cookies once they are cooled completely. Hope this helps!

  19. These look pretty and delicious! I’m going to try and make them, hope mine turn just like yours…thanks for sharing!

  20. Nametonia says:

    What did you use to make the ombre pinks?

  21. hi! I’m getting ready to make these bad boys but I had a question about the icing which may sound silly but I don’t see anywhere on the ingredients indicating anything about the coloring …. please do enlighten me as I am rookie at this 🙂

    1. Hi Rose, To get the ombre frosting effect for these cookies, all you have to do is make five different shades of pink frosting. I just portion out five bowls of icing, then add pink food coloring bit by bit to each bowl until I achieve the colors I’m looking for.

      1. oooooooh! well thank you so very much for clearing that up for me 😀

  22. Just made these for valentine’s day and they turned out perfect! They are so yummy!

  23. Hello there! I already baked these a couple of times and always turned out great! I want to make them as a guest favor in my wedding so I was just wondering how many days would they stay fresh once I bake them.

    Thank you for sharing..

    1. Glad you like the cookie recipe! I think they stay soft for 3 days. I’ve also frozen them too.

  24. I love this recipe. Thank you soooo much. I would like to make these ahead of time. Like a month. Can j freeze them. Do I freeze the dough? Can I cook a month ahead and freeze? Can I frost cooked cookies and freeze? Sorry for so many questions. Trying to save time for my busy month. 😊

    1. You can definitely freeze the dough. I prefer to freeze the dough and then thaw and bake off, rather than bake the cookies and freeze. So glad you love the cookies!

  25. Just wondering if I can chill the dough for longer than an hour? Like make the dough the night before and then cook the next day. Thanks!

  26. Does this frosting dry well? I want to be able to ship the cookies.

    1. It does dry, but when shipping these cookies, we always put wax paper between the layers of cookies. Enjoy!

  27. We have been buried in ice .snow. and freezing temps. I’ve been shoveling for ever. The last month and a half in Stevensville.Mt. I decided to try your wonderful cookies. So happy I did. Easy and they taste wonderful. Thanks you !!! Georgia

  28. These look Delicious! Do you roll the dough out to 1/4′ thickness?

    1. Yes! But sometimes I like to keep them a bit thicker, then cooking a little longer.

  29. I’m going to try to make these but how did you frost them so nicely?? Did you make a border around the cookies first? Looks so pretty!!

    1. I don’t do a border on the cookies, I’m just careful to keep the frosting on top of the cookie and not falling of the sides. I like to make my frosting a little bit on the thicker side so it doesn’t drip, that helps 🙂

  30. My dough turned out really crumbly too but I haven’t chilled it yet, what should I do?!?!

    1. Hi Traci, try adding a bit of water, a teaspoon at a time until it’s not crumbly. Then form into a disc and wrap with plastic wrap and refrigerate.

  31. I can’t wait to make these for V-day! What size cookies cutter did you use and how many did it make?

    1. I use a three inch heart cookie cutter. The recipe will make 3-4 dozen cookies, depending on how thick or thin you roll the dough out.

  32. I want to make these cookies for valentines for my kids school. Would the icing hold up in individual bags? I don’t want it to smear everywhere.

  33. I am 12 yrs old and made these for my class on valentines day, they all loved them! Thanks for the recipe!!

    1. Lola – your comment just made our day! Glad that your classmates loved them. xo

  34. Loved this recipe! Tried it out today and I’m very happy with how they turned out. Thanks 🙂

  35. NameCarrie says:

    GREAT recipe! I used 2 teaspoons vanilla bean paste and they were wonderful! The cookies are quite sweet could stand alone without icing even.

  36. Hi Melissa,
    I just finished using your recipe and I have to say that it was amazing! Every single cookie turned out perfectly and I totally love the ombre idea. I also love the way you displayed the recipe, I am in information design and I am totally using this as some inspiration for an assignment. Thanks so much for the recipe 🙂

  37. So beautiful! What size heart shape are you using?

  38. Hey I just tried these cookies out as well. Well a couple days ago. I had to leave so I left the dough to chill overnight…it was rock hard in the morning. Left it out ALL day and ALL night to today and it was still rock hard. Broke it apart and it was VERY crumbly. Anyway to salvage it?

    1. I am sorry to hear you are having trouble with the dough. We haven’t had that happen. I would recommend kneading the dough and adding a tiny bit of water.

  39. I baked these at 350° for 9 min and they were perfect. I never bake cookies at 375°😊 Haven’t iced them yet, but excited to try the ombre look!

  40. I have made your recipe and it turned out wonderful – however I found that the cookies could be sweeter – would it have a negative affect on the dough if I added an extra 1/4 of a cup of sugar ?

    1. Glad the recipe turned out for you. I am not sure about adding the additional sugar, my assumption is that it would be ok…. Sara

  41. What does the t mean before the word vanilla, water, baking soda and salt?

  42. The dough was dry so I added another egg like someone here suggested and they turned out perfect! Yummy!

  43. I made these cookies and they were a success, Everyone loved them. I didn’t do the icing sugar icing I did melted chocolate on half of the heart with sprinkles on some of them and drizzled chocolate on the other ones. Really easy recipe and taste great!!!

  44. I have made a lot of sugar cookies but this one was the tastiest! They were so soft and sweet with the icing! Love this recipe, I will be making these again and again! I’m glad I read the comments though because I had to add another egg so It wasn’t crumbly. Once I did that they were perfect!

  45. Hi

    Those cookies look cute! Is there a substitute for egg in the cookies recipe? My mom and sis are allergic to eggs 😫

    1. We have only ever used eggs – I am sorry, but I am not sure what to recommend. Good luck!

    1. We have not made these gluten free before… so I am not sure. Sorry about that. – Sara

  46. Excellent sugar cookie recipe!
    Thanks for sharing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.